Matric results and POPIA: the R5 million fine the High Court set aside
On 23 December 2024 the Information Regulator fined the Department of Basic Education (DBE) R5 million for not complying with an enforcement notice about publishing matric results in newspapers. In December 2025 a full bench of the Pretoria High Court set aside both the enforcement notice and the fine. The Regulator has applied for leave to appeal, so the matter is not finished.
By POPIA Check · Editorial update · General information, not legal advice
Timeline
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 18 November 2024 | The Regulator issues an enforcement notice ordering the department to undertake, within 31 days, not to publish the 2024 matric results in newspapers |
| 19 December 2024 | The deadline passes with no undertaking |
| 23 December 2024 | The Regulator issues an infringement notice with a R5 million administrative fine |
| 8 January 2025 | The High Court strikes the Regulator's urgent application off the roll for lack of urgency |
| 27 to 28 October 2025 | A full bench of the Pretoria High Court hears the matter and reserves judgment |
| 12 December 2025 | The Regulator notes the court's decision to set aside the enforcement notice and the infringement notice |
| 31 December 2025 | The Regulator applies for leave to appeal and says this suspends the judgment until the appeal is decided |
What the Regulator ordered
The enforcement notice ordered the department not to publish the 2024 matric results in newspapers and to make results available to learners using methods that comply with POPIA. The Regulator's view was that the way results were published was inconsistent with the Act.
What the court decided
According to the Regulator's own statements, a full bench of the Pretoria High Court set aside the enforcement notice and the infringement notice with its R5 million fine. The Regulator said it was disappointed, studied the judgment and applied for leave to appeal. It says the application suspends the judgment, so in its view the notices remain enforceable until the appeal is finally decided.
Lessons for your business
- The Regulator's decisions can be challenged in court, and courts will test them. That works through the proper process, not by ignoring a notice.
- If you receive an enforcement notice, take advice quickly. The time to appeal is short and the notice applies in the meantime unless an appeal is properly lodged.
- The underlying question, when publishing information about people is lawful, is still open in this case. Check anything you publish about people against section 11.
- Children's information needs the consent of a parent or guardian, or another authorisation in section 35.
What we do not know
We have relied on the Information Regulator's media statements, not the judgment itself. We have not confirmed whether leave to appeal was granted or how the appeal ended. Check the Regulator's website for the current position.
Common questions
Was the Department of Basic Education fined R5 million under POPIA?
The Information Regulator issued a R5 million fine on 23 December 2024. In December 2025 a full bench of the Pretoria High Court set aside the enforcement notice and the fine. The Regulator has applied for leave to appeal.
Is publishing matric results in newspapers against POPIA?
The Regulator took the view that it was inconsistent with POPIA. The High Court set aside the Regulator's notices in December 2025, and the Regulator is appealing, so the question is not finally settled.
Can a POPIA enforcement notice be challenged?
Yes. Section 97 of POPIA gives a right of appeal to the High Court within 30 days, and this case shows a court setting the Regulator's notices aside.
Sources and further reading
Editorial guidance from POPIA Check, with links to primary sources. Ask your selected legal partner how the law applies to your organisation.
- Information Regulator: infringement notice statement, 23 December 2024
- Information Regulator: statement on the court judgment, 12 December 2025
- Information Regulator: application for leave to appeal, 31 December 2025
- Information Regulator: court reserves judgment, 28 October 2025
- POPIA, Act 4 of 2013, Department of Justice
Gather the evidence. Assign the actions.
Download seven editable registers with examples and step-by-step instructions.
Get the free starter toolkitKnow what to work on next.
Get a free PDF gap report, then decide whether to discuss it with your chosen partner.
Start free assessmentView a sample report