The first POPIA fine: Department of Justice fined R5 million
On 3 July 2023 the Information Regulator issued an infringement notice to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development (DoJ&CD) with an administrative fine of R5 million. It was the first fine under POPIA. The department had not complied with an enforcement notice of 9 May 2023 that followed a security compromise on its IT systems in September 2021.
By POPIA Check · Editorial update · General information, not legal advice
The case at a glance
| Detail | What the Regulator said |
|---|---|
| Who | Department of Justice and Constitutional Development |
| Breach | September 2021: IT systems compromised, with the loss of approximately 1204 files |
| Findings | Contraventions of sections 19 and 22 of POPIA |
| Enforcement notice | 9 May 2023, with 31 days to comply |
| Infringement notice | 3 July 2023 |
| Fine | R5 million, for failing to comply with the enforcement notice |
What went wrong
The Regulator found that the department had let three security licences expire in 2020: its security incident and event monitoring (SIEM) licence, its intrusion detection system licence and its antivirus licence. Without them it could not monitor unusual activity, was not alerted to suspicious access and did not have current protection against known malware.
What the enforcement notice ordered
- Submit proof within 31 days that the antivirus, SIEM and intrusion detection licences had been renewed.
- Start disciplinary proceedings against the officials who failed to renew them.
Why the fine followed
The 31 days ended on 9 June 2023. The Regulator said it received no report and no other communication, and that the department had not used its right to appeal. It therefore found that the department had failed to comply and issued the R5 million fine.
Lessons for your business
- Renewals are a security control. Keep a calendar of security licences and subscriptions, with a named owner.
- Monitoring matters as much as prevention. Without logs you cannot tell what was taken, which is itself a finding.
- The fine was for not responding. Reply to the Regulator, on time, even if the work is still under way.
- Section 19 expects safeguards to be checked and updated regularly, not set up once.
What we do not know
This page reflects what the Information Regulator published on the dates shown. An infringement notice gives the recipient 30 days to pay, arrange instalments or elect to be tried in court, and enforcement notices can be appealed. We have not confirmed whether the fine was paid, appealed or changed afterwards. Check the Regulator's website for the current position.
Common questions
What was the first POPIA fine?
A R5 million administrative fine issued to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development on 3 July 2023.
Why was the Department of Justice fined?
For failing to comply with an enforcement notice requiring proof that expired antivirus, SIEM and intrusion detection licences had been renewed after a 2021 security compromise.
Which sections of POPIA were contravened?
The Regulator found contraventions of section 19 (security safeguards) and section 22 (notification of security compromises).
Sources and further reading
Editorial guidance from POPIA Check, with links to primary sources. Ask your selected legal partner how the law applies to your organisation.
Gather the evidence. Assign the actions.
Download seven editable registers with examples and step-by-step instructions.
Get the free starter toolkitKnow what to work on next.
Get a free PDF gap report, then decide whether to discuss it with your chosen partner.
Start free assessmentView a sample report